A family home with a landscaped front yard

Home / About Us

Meet Louis Natelli and The Natelli Agency. Local insurance help in West Chester, Pennsylvania.

The Natelli Agency is a local insurance office on West Chester Pike. Louis and our team compare more than one option for your coverage, explain it in plain English and stay with you after the policy starts.

Call (914) 419-8000 Get My Free Quote

Local

West Chester, PA

People On Our Team

Free

Quotes, No Pressure

Mon–Fri

9–5 Eastern

The Quick Answer

The Natelli Agency is a local insurance agency in West Chester, Pennsylvania, at 1240 W Chester Pike. The agent and owner is Louis Natelli, who works with a team of 6+ people.

The agency compares Farmers® and other insurance companies: Farmers comes first, and when it isn't the fit, we look at other options. That covers auto, home, renters, condo, landlord, flood, life (including final expense), motorcycle, RV and boat insurance, and business insurance for local companies.

We work with families, homeowners, renters, landlords and small businesses in West Chester, across Chester County and the Philadelphia suburbs, and elsewhere in Pennsylvania.

Quotes are free. Call (914) 419-8000, Monday to Friday, 9:00 AM to 5:00 PM Eastern.

The agent: Louis Natelli · Agent and owner
The agency: Local · more than one option
Office: 1240 W Chester Pike, West Chester, PA 19382 · serving Chester County
Hours: Mon–Fri · 9:00 AM–5:00 PM Eastern
Talk to us: (914) 419-8000

One local agency. Two ways we can help.

↓ start here ↓

For families

Protect what you've built. Your cars, your home, and the people in it.

Many of the families we help own a home or rent one, and have more than one car in the driveway. We compare your options, explain the differences in plain English, and help you pick the coverage that fits.

Home and auto quoted together, compared side by side
Free quotes from a licensed local agent
A coverage review every year as your life changes

Call (914) 419-8000

For local businesses

Coverage for the business you run. Compared and explained, not just sold.

Whether you run a shop in downtown West Chester, a contracting or service business in Chester County, or own a rental twin, the approach is the same: more than one option, compared and explained.

Business coverage for local companies
Landlord coverage for rental homes
One agency for your personal and business policies

See business coverage

Why The Natelli Agency

A local agency. Built on personal service.

Insurance is easier when you know who to call. The Natelli Agency is a local office in West Chester, so when you call, you reach a person on our team who knows the area and takes the time to understand what you're protecting.

We don't hand you one price and hope it fits. Louis is a Farmers® agent, so that's where we start, and when it isn't the right fit, we can look at other insurance companies. We lay the options side by side so you can see what each one really covers. We help you buy insurance rather than sell it to you.

The job doesn't stop at the sale. We help you set up auto coverage that goes past Pennsylvania's legal minimums and make the full vs. limited tort choice with your eyes open, build a home policy on what it would cost to rebuild, with water backup in mind, add flood coverage before the next big storm, and review life insurance as your family grows.

We help busy households, from renters near West Chester University to families juggling a mortgage, a few cars and kids' schedules, along with landlords and local business owners in West Chester, Exton, Downingtown, Malvern, Paoli, Phoenixville, Kennett Square and across Chester County.

We'll compare it, explain it and stay with you. Louis Natelli · Agent and owner, The Natelli Agency

Meet your agent

Louis Natelli. Agent and owner, The Natelli Agency.

I'm Louis Natelli, agent and owner of The Natelli Agency in West Chester. I'm a Farmers® agent, and our office helps families, homeowners, renters, landlords and small businesses across Chester County protect what they've worked for.

I want every client to understand what they're buying before they buy it. That means plain-English answers, more than one option when the first one isn't right, and a straight answer when the coverage you already have is fine.

Farmers comes first for us. When it isn't the right fit for your situation, we can look at other insurance companies, so a decline or a big renewal increase doesn't have to be the end of the conversation.

I don't do this alone. Our team of 6+ people works out of the West Chester office, and we work from one file, so whoever picks up the phone can help. We review your coverage with you every year, and when something goes wrong, we help you through the claim.

Call (914) 419-8000 Get My Free Quote

Louis Natelli, agent and owner of The Natelli Agency in West Chester, PA — **Louis Natelli**Agent and owner · The Natelli Agency

LocalAn office on West Chester Pike

OptionsMore than one, compared for you

6+People on our team

FreeQuotes and coverage reviews

Who you'll work with. A local team that knows your file.

No call center and no phone tree. When you call The Natelli Agency, you reach our West Chester team of 6+ people. We work from the same file, so you don't have to repeat your story, and you can always ask for Louis.

Louis Natelli

Agent and owner

West Chester & Chester County · Personal and business coverage

Read bio

How the agency works

More than one option, compared. One local agency in your corner.

The Natelli Agency compares Farmers® and other insurance companies for you, then walks you through the options. That covers auto, home, renters, condo, landlord, flood, life, motorcycle, RV and boat insurance, and business coverage.

Keeping your policies with one agency makes life simpler: one number to call, and one team that knows your whole picture. Bundling home and auto may lower what you pay, and we'll tell you plainly when it doesn't.

Help as your needs change

Life changes. A new teen driver, a paid-off car, a new roof, a move from a rental into your first home, a growing family, a new business. Insurance prices change too. We review your coverage with you once a year so your limits keep up, your deductibles still make sense, and you hear about the discounts you may qualify for. Discounts vary and aren't available in every situation.

Who you're working with. The short version.

Insurance runs on trust, so here's what you'd want to know before handing someone your auto, home, and family's coverage.

The agency

Local

An Office On West Chester Pike

The Natelli Agency is at 1240 W Chester Pike, West Chester, PA 19382. Stop by, or call (914) 419-8000, Monday through Friday, 9:00 AM to 5:00 PM Eastern.

The team

Six-Plus People, One File

Our team handles quotes, policy changes and questions together. Your file is shared across the office, so whoever answers can help, and you can always ask for Louis.

Licensing

Licensed

A Pennsylvania Insurance Agent

Louis is a licensed Pennsylvania insurance agent. You can check any agent's license, or get free help with an insurance question, through the Pennsylvania Insurance Department at 1-877-881-6388.

How we work. Five habits that don't change.

Education before the sale

You'll understand what you're buying before you buy it. That includes what Pennsylvania's auto minimums do and don't cover, the choice between full and limited tort, why uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage is worth keeping (you can only reject it in writing), how a water backup endorsement works on a home policy, and why a standard home policy doesn't cover flood.

We compare, you choose

Farmers comes first. When it isn't the right fit, we look at other insurance companies and lay out the trade-offs side by side. Bundling home and auto may lower what you pay. Call (914) 419-8000 to see your options.

A review every year

We sit down with you once a year, and any time life changes, to check that your limits, deductibles and discounts still fit, so your coverage doesn't quietly fall behind.

Help at claim time

When something goes wrong, call us. We'll help you start the claim with the insurance company, explain what your policy covers and help you follow up until it's settled.

A real person answers

One phone number, Monday through Friday, 9:00 AM to 5:00 PM Eastern, a team that knows your file, and messages returned within one business day. See who you'll work with.

Ready to talk about your coverage?

Auto, home, renters, condo, landlord, flood, life, motorcycle, RV, boat and business. One conversation, more than one option, zero pressure.

Call (914) 419-8000 or get a free quote online

Questions people ask about The Natelli Agency.

Who is Louis Natelli? +

Louis Natelli is the agent and owner of The Natelli Agency, a local insurance agency at 1240 W Chester Pike in West Chester, Pennsylvania. He is a Farmers® agent.

He built the agency around a simple idea: you should be able to call a real local office, get plain-English answers and see more than one option before you decide.

Do you only offer Farmers? +

No. Farmers is where we start. When that isn't the right fit for you, we can look at other insurance companies, so a decline or a big renewal increase doesn't have to be the end of the conversation.

What's available depends on your situation and the coverage you need.

What insurance can I get through your agency? +

Personal coverage: auto, home, renters, condo, landlord, flood, life (including final expense), motorcycle, and RV and boat insurance.

Business coverage for local businesses, such as general liability, commercial property and commercial auto. Availability depends on the insurance company and your situation.

What areas do you serve? +

Our office is in West Chester, in Chester County, and we work with families and businesses across Chester County and the Philadelphia suburbs, including Exton, Downingtown, Malvern, Paoli, Phoenixville, Kennett Square, Coatesville, West Goshen and East Goshen.

We can also help clients elsewhere in Pennsylvania by phone.

Who will I actually talk to when I call? +

A real person on our team at the West Chester office, not a call center or a phone tree. Our team of 6+ people works from one file, so you don't have to repeat yourself, and you can always ask for Louis.

Call (914) 419-8000, Monday through Friday, 9:00 AM to 5:00 PM Eastern. We return messages within one business day.

Do you charge a fee for a quote? +

No. Quotes are free. Call with a question and you'll get a straight answer, even when the answer is that your current coverage already fits.

Will you help me if I have a claim? +

Yes. Call us when something happens. We'll help you start the claim with the insurance company that wrote your policy, explain what your coverage includes and help you follow up.

Do you work with local businesses? +

Yes. Along with Chester County families who bundle home and auto, we work with local business owners on commercial coverage. Many owners like having their personal and business policies with one agency.

See business insurance, or call to talk it through.

Something we didn't cover? Call (914) 419-8000 or start a free quote.